Follow me on twitter

    Latest flickr photos

    personal vs professional

    July 23rd, 2008

    community bricks

    i’m currently working on the social strategy for a really fun project. it’s challenging and rewarding. it’s what i enjoy and it’s something that i’ve spent a lot of time developing. as such, i’ve gone through what i consider to be the basic steps of building a successful community:-

    1. establishing who the community is that you serve
    2. deciding what problem it is that you’re solving and how you plan to solve it
    3. working out where your community are having their conversations and how they want to be communicated with
    4. finding out what it is that interests the members of the communities, what it is that bonds them, what tools they use etc.
    5. what it is about your service/product that is actually going to distinguish you and make them give a damn

    the company thang

    having done that and established the networks i believed our users have adopted, i created corporate accounts on a number of sites that people who were interesting in what we were doing could connect with us on. for me, the benefit to this was that they’d easily be able to identify the tone and character of the brand and creates something for the company that anyone can use, rather than just myself. that makes sense right?

    well why is it then that i still find myself updating content on my own networks as well as the branded networks? you’re guaranteed if i post a link on twitter i’ll get more than ten times the response as if i were to post it on the corporate twitter account. fact.

    reputation

    the change in our culture of late has meant that people zone out when they’re being marketed to - they rarely listen to ads, hate sales people (especially those of the stripy suit variety) and can see through thinly veiled social media attempts from the old boys trying to be cool.

    someone that i barely know can recommend something on twitter or save a link on magnolia and i’m way more likely to check it out than a company persuading me to do so.

    do your job

    Brian Oberkirch recently wrote a really interesting piece about consumers not wanting to be talked to all of the time and i couldn’t agree more. for me, the perfect combination is having a company that let’s me have a nose (without that annoying person on your back asking if they can help until you have enough and leave) but is still on hand if you get lost and need a little point in the right direction.

    the perfect company is one that uses their products and services as much as you, knows it inside out and is part of the conversation because they truly have something interesting to contribute, not because they feel they need to be seen to still be in the loop.

    the insider

    if the truth be known i think that people want to know who’s behind the scenes, they want to interact with someone that they know or have heard of, they want to know you’ve got flaws as well as sheen (why do you think so many mags sell when there’s pics of celebrities with blemishes - people don’t like perfection).

    i realise for corporations that brings with it issues. you can’t rely on your marketing coming from a few individuals, after all what happens when those people leave? i’ve thought about this issue long and hard and i’m still not sure that i know the answer to be honest. it is a risk, but it’s a risk that you need to take, at the beginning anyway. surely it’s better you have people doing a bloody good job and getting your product or service out there into the domain and cross the other bridges when you come to them - after all, the hope would be that the brand would be well recognised by the time that happened?

    the solution that i’ve settled for is to use both personal and professional. i converse with community members using the corporate name, encouraging people to recognise that there’s a human voice behind it. however, those same community members are also more than welcome to talk to me using my personal accounts. on twitter for example, my followers know if they follow me, they’ll hear about good days, bad days and the days where my heel snapped on the way to work. if they follow the work twitter account, they’ll hear about website developments, legal issues and exciting launches.

    it becomes a different issue again when you throw seeding companies into the mix… but i won’t even get into that here. maybe i’m a small town girl with small town ideas but i’m going to stick with my beliefs. my beliefs that if you’re genuine, you care and you want to make a difference, your community will build. have nothing to hide, don’t be afraid to wear your heart on your sleeve and willing to share (collaboration is much more fulfilling than the feeling of hiding your ideas to keep that competitive advantage!).

    onwards and upwards

    it’s really not an easy situation to tackle and i think you need to remain open and flexible with your approach. be okay with the fact that you’re learning and developing - you’re on a journey and given time, your community members will be coming along for the ride too. i’d be really interested to hear how others approach this issue…

    Tags: , , , , ,

    7 Responses to “personal vs professional”

    1. Jorge Says:

      I think that the approach needs to be a mix of it. For example Mahalo Daily took Veronica Belmont and the people following her to make Mahalo a known site and service. But once Veronica left Mahalo continues to grow because the people came in touch with the quality of the site.

      So if the people that do the marketing leave the users will not necessarily leave too. Of course, some may leave or stop using the service, but some will stay and hopefully that person will be replaced with another one that will draw more people to the service or product.

    2. Dennis Says:

      Great post Mel. Jorge - I think that’s what Mel was saying. I’ve also been tackling the same topic myself and I think you’re right as long as you’re genuine about the people behind the product or service as well as the actual product or service itself you should be on to a winner.

    3. Kevin Says:

      This is really a good stuff Mel. Very keen observations. As someone who is in the midst of creating a new online community site, this post really gives me some insight into the idea of which is better: personal or professional and how to describe it to those in management who feel the brand will surely be the dominant party. It doesn’t necessarily work like that from what I see.

      I think it all comes down to trust. When I a receive a reply from a “company”, I always get the feeling of it being an autonomous being with only its own company interests in mind. To me that is the challenge of overcoming that feeling I am certain is in other people’s opinions.

    4. Jorge Says:

      @Dennis. Yes in fact i was agreeing with Mel.

      Another thing that just came to me it’s that maybe this needs steps.
      First get the people promote it mainly in a personal way and then get it professional and give more power to the professional approach without leaving the personal one. Little by little give more power to the professional until both have some followers. If you change the person that is the contact then use the professional one to introduce the new person and also the old contact account to make it.

      It’s easier to say than to do of course. People like to feel the approach of talking to someone with a name, a face and a personality than talking to a company. I think that as humans we are made to socialize with other humans and not with companies, so the personal part needs to be there all the time. The example i’m more familiar with is the Mahalo Daily one, which i followed particularly.

      Thanks for the post Mel it gives the correct approach (at leat in my opinion).

    5. Jeremiah Says:

      I have to agree with you that a the perfect company is one that uses their products and services as much as you and knows it inside out…..

      as to personal vs professional - I tend to use tools like twitter for both… my work and my personal life blend into each other. As you build a community, I think people find it easier to relate to you when they have a peek into your personal life. I like the video you posted of listening to music because you forgot to turn off the camera… that was a peek into your life… some would say.. “that was Mel being Mel”

    6. The Personal Era « BRKOPP: The Break Operation Says:

      [...] established that, the first discovery made by Mel Kirk on her Personal vs. Professional post is that you can get up to 10 time more responses from a personal account than from a business [...]

    7. Mel Kirk Says:

      totally agree with all of your points… i think there’s no fast and sure solution but it is something that happens in phases. Jeremiah has a really good point when it comes to people getting an inside glimpse - that’s why office cams and behind the scenes footage always goes down well…

      any further thoughts and ideas would be appreciated and maybe i can accumulate in another post…
      :)

    Leave a Reply